WHO WAS THE FIRST AMERICAN LEAGUE PLAYER TO HIT FOUR CONSECUTIVE HOME RUNS IN ONE GAME? July 14, 2017 By Show answer LOU GEHRIG, ON JUNE 3, 1932. GEHRIG, PLAYING FOR THE NEW YORK YANKEES, HIT FOUR-BAGGERS IN THE FIRST , FOURTH, FIFTH AND SEVENTH INNINGS AGAINST PHILADELPHIA. THE YANKEES WON, 20-13 More Baseball QuestionsMore Sports Questions